e.g.r block off plate

[two-step-n]

the new egr block offs

[cre]

You should post these in your build thread so people know there more to it.

[two-step-n]

Originally Posted by cre

You should post these in your build thread so people know there more to it.

i did the other day

[cre]

So just looking to bump your thread count? Sorry, I just don't get why this needs two threads... am I missing something?

[two-step-n]

yeah its looks like an egr block off just showing people how i blocked the egr off! did i miss something?

[MA70-3.0GT]

Seems fair enough to me, not everyone who wants to bin the EGR is gonna be reading the build thread... Woohoo I got 17 posts!!!

[cre]

Sorry, I was just waiting for more info or something... just hit me as more of a "look what I have" thread when it's already been shown. I just think people need to step it up a bit in this group...empty threads like this make for poor reference as there is no text (hence no key words) for a future user to have much luck finding it and also the fact that most newbies have no idea what the EGR system is or what it does or why you'd remove it.





E.G.R. = Exhaust Gas Reticulation system. The EGR is an emissions control device with a nice bonus; It's used to cool the engine and thus reduce NOx emissions. The EGR system is only active at part throttle driving (not at idle and not at WOT) and as such does not affect power output at loads of around 70% or higher. While it doesn't affect things at WOT it does help coold the engine back down more quickly when you come back off of it. It's a popular device for people to remove either for cosmetic reasons (as is the case in two-step-n's build, which isn't mentioned here) or just due to the false belief that it will net them more power. In newer vehicles the system is also temperature controlled to ensure that the exhaust gasses are just the right temp to do the job.

Honda has been using an aggressive EGR type of system for decades now as a means of boosting their fuel economy. As the EGR system dumps inert gasses back into the engine it effectively reduces the engine's overall displacement. Take a 3 liter engine, add one liter of inert gas and BAM! you're now running a more fuel efficient two liter.... but only until you floor it. Sadly, the system doesn't move enough gas in our vehicles to help out in a big way with the mileage thing.

The most common issue that people have with the EGR system is that the actuator or the vacuum diaphragm will stick, leaving the system open. This can cause problems with the vehicle at idle and will most certainly result in power loss at higher loads when it should otherwise be shut off. **It can also be a big annoyance to work around if you're constantly servicing the engine as in the case of a race car.

And here's a Toyota technical article about it if you want more in depth reading:
http://www.autoshop101.com/forms/h61.pdf

[MA70-3.0GT]

S'pose your right, although with EGR being such a common system on cars nowadays almost anyone with previous mechanical experience is likely to have already run across a sticky EGR valve at some point or at least read about someone else's troubles with it.

Even my old Pajero has the damn thing (it lasted about ten minutes before I disconnected it, as it wasn't already stuck open I decided not to give it the chance to!).

I never even considered anyone would remove one for cosmetic reasons, simply because most people I know just remove the vac. pipe (or blank it if already stuck) to avoid/cure running issues, provided the vehicle in question can pass emissions without.

I think over here they have a worse reputation than they deserve because most stuff a few years old will easily pass our emissions test without EGR operating so people fail to see the point, and when one eventually does stick open the system in general gets tarred with the same brush.

[cre]

That's a waste of effort really. These fail so infrequently that the benefits (reduced engine temps, higher spark advance, reduced knock) outweigh the potential headache, IMO... especially on an engine which likes to go through head gaskets . Disconnecting the vacuum lines doesn't mean the system won't vent, a broken actuator will leak regardless, a block off is the only way to fully ensure closure. Otherwise, you still need to diagnose the system if you have related problems.

You're also assuming that people who come here for help have experience with this kind of thing. Most don't have that much and as such shouldn't be encouraged to make changes they don't understand both the pros and cons to.


Pros: Reduced engine temps, better fuel economy (minimal on MKIII's), higher spark advance, reduced knock. These are all HUGE at mid-high loads when the combustion cylinder temps are the highest and the engine is more prone to knock.

Cons: If it leaks, your car will have issues at idle, possibly while it's warming up and it will cost you some power at WOT; it's not pretty; and it can be a pain in the ass to work around if the engine is still in the car... I HATE that part.



EDIT: Oh, it's not just the way things are over there... Over here it's much the same. A long time ago the old muscle car guys decided that anything they didn't understand and absolutely ANYTHING called an emissions device was bad... let's just forget the whole thing about science and 40 years of continued research and developments... Ignorance is not something to be proud of, yet it seems so many people like to wear it as a badge.

[two-step-n]

thats the 2nd egr to stick on me so i didnt wanted it anymore and it looks better without one i think! I also don't need to worry about emissions anymore because the car is registered up North where emission testing isn't required.